Sunken Locomotives in Canada



From time to time we receive reports, stories, rumours about locomotives that have fallen into lakes, rivers or swamps and have been left there.  We will list these here by province together with any corroborating evidence we can obtain. It should be emphasized that many of these stories are just that - a story with no hard evidence to back it up.

British Columbia

Anderson Lake Pacific Great Eastern 2-8-0 #56 hit a rock slide and fell into Anderson Lake on August 12, 1944.  #56 remains in Anderson Lake.

Kaslo Lake Canadian Pacific 2-8-0 No. 3512 fell off a barge in Slocan Lake on 31 December 1946.  See 'The Shipwrecked Hogger', CRHA #256A of May 1973 which also refers to page 83 of Bulletin Number 83 of the Railway & Locomotive Historical Society of Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A.

Seton Lake Pacific Great Eastern 2-8-0 #53 hit a rock slide at Mile 117 on January 3, 1950, and derailed into Seton Lake, killing the engineer and fireman.  #53 remains in Seton Lake.

New Brunswick

Saint John River Bridge see http://www.locomotive508.nb.ca/journal1.htm

Saint John River, Canadian Pacific, Shogomoc Subdivision, mileage 82.7. RS18 8739 is still buried in a washout near Bath, NB., which occurred on 1 April 1976.  It was officially retired on 12 May 1976.

Ontario

  Marlbank  An industrial locomotive is reputed to have fallen into the water and is buried up to its stack in silt/clay.  The stack has been seen from time to time. If this is the case this will likely be an 0-4-0ST, No. 34 which was used in the area in the 1890s.  A picture of No. 34 can be seen at:
http://www.ghosttownpix.com/ontario/img/marlimg.shtml

  Meath  There is a locomotive buried up at what CP used to call Meath siding, where highway 17 crosses the Chalk River Subdivision just east of Pembroke, near the cropssing of the Mukrat River.  When the CPR was being built through the area, it was quite swampy, and I think still is.  One of the construction engines supposedly keeled over and sank in the quicksand in the 1880's, and apparently is there to this day, although probably well chewed up by time. (Bruce Chapman)

  Mud Lake  I am wondering about a rumoured sunken locomotive in or near Mud Lake. I've heard this tale several times, and many years ago spoke to a diver who claimed to have seen the locomotive and remains of one or two freight cars. What the diver described to me sounded like a 4-4-0, but take this with a very large grain of salt. He wasn't a railfan, just someone who claimed to have found something interesting.The story comes in two flavours, one on the O&Q near Mud Lake, and one on the new line in Mud Lake. (Steve Hunter)

  Sherkston  David Gilchrest has seen two quarry locomotives in 35 feet of water in the Empire Limestone quarry at Sherkston, near Port Colbourne.  The quarry and its equipment was abandoned in 1910 and was later flooded.

 
Port Arthur (Thunder Bay) An industrial 0-4-0 shunter used in building the breakwater in Port Arthur harbour was either scrapped by running it into the drink or it fell in. This occurred about 1910. I know it is there because my father, who was GM of Port Arthur Shipbuilding, sent a diver down to take a look. It was there alright, and the brass whistle was recovered. I have it somewhere among my railway bits. (David Page).  This would be one of the narrow gauge Chambers, McQuigge and McCaffrey locomotives listed under Port Arthur in the Industrial Locomotive Listing at:

http://www.railways.incanada.net/industrials/Ontario.pdf

  Thunder Bay (Gunflint Lake) There was a rumour in Port Arthur that a Shay logging loco had fallen into Gunflint Lake, about 50mi. SW of the Lakehead at some point in the 30s-40s. Never confirmed, but I recall hearing someone say that they had seen it. This is possibly the shay (Lima 2712 of 12/1913) now displayed at Atikokan (David Page)

Quebec

St. Lawrence River if anybody would have a lead on the ship's log from the steamship Merlin from December 1881, I'd be most grateful... there's a certain little PEIR Hunslet 4-4-0T on the bottom of the Gulf of St. Lawrence... somewhere.. (Steve Hunter)

Thurso  Parts of the first locomotive owned by the Thurso and Nation Valley Railway may have been dumped into Cairo Lake, mile 27.75 in 1936. 
See http://www.railways.incanada.net/thurso/tnvrloco.htm#no.1


Updated July 2008